Humor Urban Legends Did Nostradamus Predict the 9/11 Attacks? Internet rumors claim the French seer anticipated the tragedy Share PINTEREST Email Print Robert Giroux / Getty Images Urban Legends Classic & Historic Legends Urban Legends in the News Rumors & Hoaxes Animal Folklore Scary Stories By David Emery David Emery is an internet folklore expert, and debunker of urban legends, hoaxes, and popular misconceptions. He currently writes for Snopes.com. our editorial process David Emery Updated August 14, 2018 Did 16th-century astrologer Nostradamus predict the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon? According to online rumors, the French physician anticipated the attacks in his manuscript "The Prophecies." But the he-told-you-so messages, while intriguing, take some liberties with the truth and should be viewed with skepticism. Who Was Nostradamus? Nostradamus, the most famous astrologer who ever lived, was born Michel de Nostredame in France in 1503. The alleged seer wrote the first edition of his "Prophecies" in 1555. Each of the book's four-line verses (or "quatrains") purported to foretell world events far into the future. Since Nostradamus' time, the astrologer's devotees have claimed that the man accurately predicted wars, natural disasters, and the rise and fall of empires. Critics, however, argue that Nostradamus wrote his "prophetic" verses in language so obscure that the words can be, and have been, interpreted to mean almost anything. What's more, the interpretations are always done after the fact, with the benefit of hindsight, and with the aim of proving the relevance of a given passage to an actual event. Alleged Prediction of 9/11 Attacks "Spooky" quatrains allegedly foretelling the events of 9/11 with incredible specificity began circulating online within hours of the first jetliner crash in New York City—completely bogus quatrains, as it turned out. In this case, it wasn't a question of whether or not the quatrains were being interpreted accurately. Nostradamus simply didn't write them. The first quatrain to hit email inboxes on 9/11 contained the prediction that a "great thunder" would be heard in the "City of God": "In the City of God there will be a great thunder,Two brothers torn apart by Chaos,while the fortress endures, the great leader will succumb,The third big war will begin when the big city is burning"- Nostradamus 1654 Assuming the "City of God" is New York City, then the "two brothers torn apart by Chaos" must be the fallen towers of the World Trade Center. The "fortress" is clearly the Pentagon, the "great leader" the United States of America, and "the third big war" must be World War III. If you're looking for coincidences, these words might seem pretty spooky. But closer scrutiny shows that they raise more questions than they answer. For example, what earthly (or unearthly) justification could Nostradamus have had for describing New York City (which did not yet even exist) as "the City of God"? Why did the great seer refer to the future World Trade Center towers as "two brothers" instead of using a more apt word like "buildings" or "monuments" (or even "towers")? In the end, though, quibbling over individual words is futile, since Nostradamus didn't even write this passage. In fact, Michel de Nostredame died in 1566, nearly 100 years before the date given in the email (1654). The quatrain is nowhere to be found in his entire published oeuvre. In a word, it's a hoax. More precisely, its attribution to Nostradamus is a hoax. The passage was lifted from a web page (long since deleted from the server that initially hosted it) containing an essay written by college student Neil Marshall in 1996 entitled "Nostradamus: A Critical Analysis." In the essay, Marshall admits inventing the quatrain for the purpose of demonstrating—quite ironically, in light of the way it was subsequently misused—how a Nostradamus-like verse can be so cryptically written as to lend itself to whatever interpretation one wishes to make. Interestingly, a variant of this faux prophecy turned up in an online newsgroup only one day after 9/11 under the heading "They followed his prediction." It went like this: In the City of God there will be a great thunder, Two brothers torn apart by Chaos, while the fortress endures, the great leader will succumb''The third big war will begin when the big city is burning'- Nostradamus 1654...on the 11 day of the 9 month that... two metal birds would crash into two tall statues... in the new city... and the world will end soon after""From the book of Nostradamus" Here again, though the text features all the pomp and vagueness one finds in Nostradamus' actual writings, this particular passage does not exist, in whole or in part, anywhere in the "Prophecies." This, too, is an internet hoax, a cheeky elaboration on Neil Marshall's invented quatrain. Two Steel Birds The third example of Nostradamus allegedly predicting 9/11 is "spookier" yet: Subject: Re: NostradamusCentury 6, Quatrain 97Two steel birds will fall from the sky on the Metropolis. The sky will burn at forty-five degrees latitude. Fire approaches the great new city (New York City lies between 40-45 degrees)Immediately a huge, scattered flame leaps up. Within months, rivers will flow with blood. The undead will roam earth for little time. This passage, it turns out, is not entirely fake. Rather, it is what you might call an "imaginative revision" of an actual verse from the "Prophecies." The authentic passage on which it is based is usually translated from the French as: The sky will burn at forty-five degrees latitude,Fire approaches the great new cityImmediately a huge, scattered flame leaps upWhen they want to have verification from the Normans. As you can see, Nostradamus made no mention of "two steel birds" in the original passage, nor did he predict that "the undead will roam the earth." As for the geographical location of New York City, it is found at exactly 40 degrees, 42 minutes, 51 seconds north. So, while it isn't false to say that it lies "between 40-45 degrees," it is imprecise, not to mention an obvious, disingenuous ploy to make what Nostradamus actually wrote ("The sky will burn at forty-five degrees latitude") seem germane to the events of September 11, 2001.